: Agree or Disagree (Y8)
Trend task
Loading Images
Approach: Team Level: Year 8
Focus: Stereotypes
Resources: 8 picture cards with statements, “Agree/Disagree” chart, 4 prompt cards, recording sheet, “Working Together” card

Questions/instructions:

Show and explain Working Together card.
Place pile of cards, upside down, on table.


For this activity, we have eight cards. Each card says something that you may or may not agree with. Let’s see which you agree with and which you do not agree with. We’ll look at one card at a time.

The first person (Student 1) will take a card from the top of the pile, and then read what is on it to the others. They’ll also show the others the picture.

Each of the other people, in turn, will say if they agree or do not agree with the statement and give their reasons.

worrking together
[Click on card to enlarge.]

After everyone has done this, the person who read out the statement will decide whether to agree or disagree with the statement. They’ll put the card on this chart, to show what they have decided.

Place Agree/Don’t Agree chart in front of team.
When the person has put the card on the chart, he or she explains their reasons to the others.

The next person in the team then picks up another card, and the process is repeated until all the cards have been discussed and placed on the chart.
Here is a prompt card to remind you what to do.

Hand out prompt cards to each student. Let’s start with (Student 1’s name).


% responses
2006 ('02)
y8
Card 1: It’s OK for men to cry  
crying man
Final decision:
agree
94 (98)
disagree
5 (2)
neither agree nor disagree
1 (0)
How well was the case for that decision made?



extremely/very well
3 (2)
well
13 (28)
moderately well
58 (56)
poorly
26 (14)
Card 2: Thin people are fitter than fat people.
thin people
Final decision:
agree
26 (30)
disagree
71 (68)
neither agree nor disagree
3 (2)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
9 (4)
well
18 (14)
moderately well
38 (57)
poorly
35 (25)
Card 3: Girls can be as good as boys at playing rugby.
rugby girl
Final decision:
agree
87 (79)
disagree
11 (19)
neither agree nor disagree
2 (2)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
3 (3)
well
21 (23)
moderately well
49 (51)
poorly
27 (23)
Card 4: Women rather than men should do the cooking and housework.
women in kitchen
Final decision:
agree
16 (9)
disagree
82 (89)
neither agree nor disagree
2 (2)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
4 (2)
well
23 (25)
moderately well
50 (53)
poorly
23 (20)
Card 5: Old people don’t understand how young people feel.
old man
Final decision:
agree
28 (32)
disagree
70 (63)
neither agree nor disagree
2 (5)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
4 (0)
well
17 (16)
moderately well
55 (67)
poorly
24 (17)
Card 6: Children in wheelchairs should have their own schools.
wheelchair boy
Final decision:
agree
24 (21)
disagree
74 (79)
neither agree nor disagree
2 (0)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
11 (10)
well
28 (29)
moderately well
52 (54)
poorly
9 (7)
Card 7: Only women should wear earrings.
earrings
Final decision:
agree
8 (12)
disagree
92 (88)
neither agree nor disagree
0 (0)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
4 (4)
well
23 (10)
moderately well
47 (63)
poorly
26 (23)
Card 8: All New Zealanders should learn to speak Mäori
card 8 maori
Final decision:
agree
24 (18)
disagree
71 (79)
neither agree nor disagree
5 (3)
How well was the case for that decision made?
extremely/very well
6 (4)
well
29 (28)
moderately well
52 (51)
poorly
13 (17)

Total score:
15–24
11 (7)
12–14
16 (16)
9–11
19 (25)
6–8
28 (38)
0–5
26 (14)
Commentary:
The total score was based on the reasons for choices, not the choices themselves. Subgroup graphs are not included because this was a team task. There was a slightly greater spread of performance in 2006 than 2002, with more high and low scores. (Agree or Disagree? (Y4))
Loading Images