Resources:
Ten
photographs. Mäori translations of the signs were presented on a
card.
Questions
/ instructions:
Im
going to show you some pictures of signs. Signs usually give us
messages or tell us something.
As you look at each picture, try to do two things: read out loud
the words on the sign, then tell me what you think the sign means.
Anei
ngä whakaahua o ngä tohu. He tikanga körero anö
tä ngä tohu mö tätou.
I a koe e titiro ana ki ia whakaahua me mahi koe i ënei mea
e rua; pänui ä-wahatia ngä kupu o te tohu; whakamäramatia
mai te tïkanga o te tohu.
[select
to view large Translation Card]
%
responses
GEd
MI
Show
student each sign in order from 1 to 10. Say, Heres picture
number 1; Heres picture number 2, etc.
Ask the two questions for each sign (below). Dont give help
with reading words. Do give encouragement to try.
1.
Read the words on the sign.
2.
Explain what you think the sign means without just reading out the words.
1.
Pänui ä-wahatia ngä kupu o te tohu.
2. Whakamäramatia mai te tikanga o te tohu, kaua e pänui noa
iho.
read
words accurately
100
95
explained
vehicles cant go in this way
96
89
read
words accurately
82
73
explained
you can use a phone here with a Telecom card
84
47
read
words accurately
97
89
explained
you can get fish & chips here
92
87
explained
you can drive in to get them
88
68
read
words accurately
91
86
explained
gates will be closed at 5.30pm
80
84
read
words accurately
88
89
explained
you should not block this area, it might be needed as a fire exit.
62
63
read
words accurately
95
78
Explained : you can park here
for McDonalds
67
76
you
can be towed away if you park here and dont go to McDonalds
49
50
read
words accurately
83
73
explained
that dogs are not allowed in this area
99
97
no
more than 2 words incorrect
96
83
explained
that ducks should not be fed here
64
84
explained
where ducks should be fed
63
66
explained
why
55
45
read
words accurately
94
78
explained
no bikes of any sort allowed here
72
71
no
more than 1 word wrong
87
75
explained
construction going on
64
42
explained
walk on opposite path
71
63
Total
score:
21 25
53
39
17
20
33
36
13
16
13
9
9
12
1
3
5
8
0
3
0
4
0
0
Commentary:
Mäori students in general education (GEd) settings scored statistically
significantly higher than did Mäori students in Mäori immersion
(MI) settings.