Approach: One
to one
|
Focus:
Adjusting water
level in a glass to try to match pitch of a chime bar.
|
|
948k |
Resources:
Water bottle, jug of
water, F chime bar, G chime bar, beater, crystal glass tumbler. |
Questions
/ instructions:
Place chime bars
F and G and beater in front of student.
When you hit chime bars they make a sound. These two chime bars make
different sounds. Play them now so that you can hear the sounds they
make.
After student has played each chime bar, place glass tumbler and
jug of water in front of student.
When you tip water into a glass and hit the side of the glass, it makes
a sound. You can change the sound by changing the amount of water in
the glass.
Temporarily remove the F chime bar from the student.
In this activity you are going to tip water into the glass to make a
sound. First, try to make the same sound as you hear when you play the
G chime bar. When you are putting water into the glass you will need
to keep checking the sound by hitting the side of the glass AND the
chime bar. If you think there is too much water in the glass you can
tip some back into the jug. When you think they are both making the
same sound, tell me.
Student attempts to make chimebar G sound with the water in the
glass.
|
|
%
responses
|
y4
|
y8
|
Matching
the G |
very
close
|
6
|
13
|
|
moderately
close
|
19
|
29
|
moves
in right direction
|
33
|
33
|
no
useful progress
|
42
|
25
|
When completed,
remove chime bar G and replace with chime bar F.
Tip water back into jug.
Now see if you can
make the same sound as the F chime bar. Tell me when you think the glass
and the chime bar are making the same sound.
Student attempts
to make the F sound with the water in the glass.
|
Matching
the F |
very close
|
3
|
12
|
|
moderately
close
|
12
|
22
|
moves
in the right direction
|
42
|
37
|
no
useful progess
|
43
|
29
|
Commentary:
Despite care to choose crystal glasses that 'rang' well, most students
struggled with this task. More than 40 percent of year 4 students and
25 percent of year 8 students made no useful progress (their adjustments
of water level seemed almost random). |