Approach: One
to one |
Level: Year
4 and year 8 |
|
Focus:
Retelling a process. |
|
740k |
Resources:
Video recording on
laptop computer, tyre tube and puncture repair kit. |
Questions
/ instructions:
Video showed
bicycle technician Peter Goding checking tube for a puncture,
repairing it, reinflating and checking for further leaks.
Have you ever
fixed a bike puncture?
Have you ever
watched someone else fix a bike puncture?
We are going
to watch a video showing how to fix a bike puncture once the tube
has been taken out of the tyre. After watching the video, I want
you to tell me what you would do to fix a puncture.
Click the Play button to start the video.
Now I want you to explain to me, as clearly as you can, how you
would fix a puncture. Here is a bike tube and a puncture repair
kit. Use these to show and explain how you would fix the puncture.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
%
responses
2000 ('96) |
y4
|
y8
|
Steps
included |
pump
tube up |
51
(48) |
81
(86) |
|
find hole |
78
(64) |
93
(97) |
check
for other holes |
31
(31) |
55
(56) |
rough
up tube with sandpaper |
65
(73) |
86
(94) |
roughened
area as large as patch |
5
(2) |
20
(20) |
put
glue on roughened area |
93
(98) |
97
(97) |
wait
for glue to dry |
72
(77) |
86
(84) |
peel
cover off patch |
39
(41) |
63
(63) |
place
patch over area of glue/hole |
74
(68) |
79
(82) |
press
down firmly |
30
(29) |
53
(53) |
peel
off backing paper |
57
(57) |
77
(74) |
check
all edges pressed down |
27
(33) |
46
(52) |
pump
up tube |
16
(15) |
29
(39) |
check
for leaks |
24
(20) |
43
(40) |
Sequencing
|
all
steps mentioned are in correct order |
53
(45) |
61
(59) |
|
1
or more steps out of order, but later corrected |
21
(28) |
29
(28) |
1
step out of order |
12
(15) |
6
(9) |
2
steps out of order |
5
(7) |
3
(0) |
explanation
jumbled or very incomplete |
9
(5) |
1
(4) |
Speech
clarity |
very
clear and well articulated |
19
(22) |
44
(50) |
|
some
minor limitations |
62
(64) |
54
(46) |
significant
limitations |
17
(14) |
2
(4) |
very
hard to understand |
2
(0) |
0
(0) |
Total
score: |
1619
|
2
(1) |
24
(22) |
|
1315
|
27
(23) |
45
(50) |
1012
|
43
(46) |
25
(22) |
79
|
19
(24) |
5
(6) |
46
|
6
(3) |
1
(0) |
03
|
3
(3) |
0
(0) |
Commentary:
On average 18 percent more year 8 than year 4 students succeeded with
each task component, with 40 percent more gaining a total score of 13
or more. The 2000 results were very similar to the 1996 results, at both
year levels. |