Approach: One
to one |
Focus:
Explain the operation
of measuring instrument and predict the effects of alterations of its components. |
|
496k |
Resources: Scientific
instrument: thermometer. |
Questions / instructions:
In this activity I want you
to try to explain how a bit of equipment works.
Give the student the thermometer.
Now have a look at this.
|
|
|
|
%
response
|
y4
1999(1995)
|
y8
1999(1995)
|
|
1.
What do people use this piece of equipment for? |
to
measure temperature
|
65
(75)
|
90
(96)
|
If
the student doesn't know, tell them it is used to find out what the temperature
is. |
a
|
a
|
2. What
is this piece of equipment called? |
thermometer
|
44
(47)
|
83
(26)
|
If
the student doesn't know tell them it is a thermometer |
a
|
a
|
3.
Can you explain how the thermometer works? |
Rising
temperature causes liquid to expand, pushing it along the tubing.
clear
and correct
|
3
(10)
|
16
(25)
|
limited
understanding
|
66
(40)
|
71
(45)
|
4.
What would happen: |
a
|
a
|
if you put the thermometer in some boiling water? |
measures
100C; (at sea level)
|
8
(8)
|
29
(29)
|
goes
to top
|
57
(66)
|
43
(55)
|
if you put the thermometer in something that is 130C?
|
breaks
|
20
(20)
|
40
(46)
|
goes
to top
|
33
(43)
|
38
(39)
|
Point
to the appropriate part of the thermometer for the student: |
a
|
a
|
5.
What would happen: |
a
|
a
|
if the hole in the long part of the thermometer
was fatter? |
move
less as temperature changed
|
3
(11)
|
10
(16)
|
|
read
lower
|
15
(9)
|
28
(18)
|
|
be
inaccurate
|
5
(14)
|
14
(12)
|
if the bulb was made of thicker glass? |
take longer to register temperature change
|
7
(20)
|
29
(46)
|
Commentary:
Year 8 students performed substantially better than year 4 students. Changes in
performance between 1995 and 1999 were mixed, with some improvements and some
declines in performance. Overall, there was a small decline in performance. |