Approach: Team |
Level:
Year 8 only |
|
Focus:
Cooperatively
plan, carry out and report on an experiment involving the effects of mass and
rotational inertia on the acceleration of a wheel. |
|
712k |
Resources: 2
wheel cases, 8 washers, 2cm blutak, test track, cork, red pen, blue pen, large
paper (for planning), stop watch, instruction card. |
Questions / instructions:
I want you to imagine that
you are a team of scientists who design wheels. You are to experiment and conduct
tests with different kinds of wheels to find one that will gain speed most easily.
You will need to think about the weight of the wheels. You
also need to think about how you can arrange the washers inside the wheels. The
washers act as weights. To help you with your work, you have two containers that
can act as wheels, 8 washers that can be used as weights in the wheels, some blutak
for joining and arranging washers in the wheels, a cork and a test track for checking
the speed of the wheels that you design. A stop watch is also available if you
want to use it.
Show students each of the supplies, but don't give them out yet.
So that everyone takes part in the reporting, I'm going to ask [name students
1 and 2] to report to me on what you did, later I'll ask [name students 3 and
4] to tell me your results and the best way to make a wheel that gains speed most
easily. You can have a couple of minutes now to talk about what you will say in
your explanations to me. This card describes the three things your team is asked
to do.
Place the card for all students to see, then read it to the team.
Give the planning sheet and the blue pen to the students. Teacher withdraws,
and allows students time to plan their explanations.
[Name students 1 and 2] I want you to tell me the plan of your experiment.
The others can help with the explanations if that would be helpful.
Allow time.
|
a |
a |
a |
%
responses
|
y8
|
Planning: |
a
|
a |
to
try different arrangements of washers
|
44
|
to
achieve consistant set up and release of wheel on ramp
|
7
|
to
achieve accurate measurement of speed/time
|
19
|
to
check consistency by replication
|
4
|
to
involve all students
|
56
|
Report
on planning: |
a
|
a |
clear,
accurate, full
|
9
|
reasonably
clear, accurate
|
54
|
You
have 10 minutes to work through your experiment. If you make changes, use the
red pen to write these down on your planning sheet. After that I will ask you
to report to me on what you did, to tell me your results, and to explain what
is the best way to make a wheel that gains speed most easily. Use all of your
time well, so that you get the best results.
Give students the equipment. Take in the blue pen and give students the red
pen. Allow 10 minutes for the experiment.
[Name students 3 and 4]: I want you to tell me your results and to explain the
best way to make a wheel that is fast at picking up speed. The others can help
with the explanations if that would be helpful. |
a
|
a |
Experimentation: |
a
|
a |
tried
several different arrangements of washers systematically
|
31
|
set
up and released wheel consisently
|
25
|
measured
speed/time carefully
|
25
|
included
replication of most/all trials
|
22
|
high
participation
|
60
|
Report
on experiments: |
a
|
a |
clear,
accurate, full
|
2
|
reasonably
clear and accurate
|
24
|
Commentary:
The apparatus for this task was not easy to use, which perhaps accounts for the
modest proportions of teams who achieved high standards in the different aspects
of experimentation. Important aspects were often not considered in the planning. |