Approach: One
to one |
Level:
Year 4
and year 8 |
|
Focus:
Electricity
|
Resources:
Torch bulb, battery
(cell) in holder, red and green wires with alligator clips
|
|
640KB |
|
|
Questions/instructions:
In this activity you’re going to try to make a torch bulb
shine.
Show students the equipment. |
|
|
|
%
responses
2003 ('99) |
y4
|
y8 |
1.
Here is the equipment for you to use. Try to connect it so the bulb shines.
If you can’t manage to make the bulb shine I’ll help you.
Allow time for the student to attempt the task independently.
Only use the following prompts if the student needs help.
Prompts: Use each end of the battery holder.
Put the alligator clips on these bits of the battery holder.(Point
to the appropriate bits.)
Touch the bulb with both wires.
|
working
independently, student got bulb to shine |
16
(31) |
49
(43) |
If necessary assist the student to make bulb shine.
|
|
|
2.
Look at your equipment and try to explain to me what made the bulb work?
Prompt: What makes the light shine?
|
complete
path/circuit for electricity to flow |
8
(9) |
31
(18) |
the
battery pumps electricity/power/energy around the circuit |
9
(6) |
19
(11) |
the
battery has energy/power in it |
41
(38) |
48
(40) |
the
electricity goes through a thin wire (filament)
and makes it hot and it glows |
2
(3) |
4
(4) |
3.
Look at the red wire and the green wire.
Is the same amount of electricity flowing through both wires, or does
one wire have more electricity flowing through it than the other wire?
|
same
|
40
(62) |
49
(57) |
4.
Why do you say that?
|
good
explanation for “same”
(same amount has to go out as comes in, current electrons flow all around
circuit) |
2
(8) |
7
(7) |
incorrect
explanation for “different” (electricity
used up in bulb) |
[7 (7)] |
[12
(1)] |
5.
Why do batteries usually go flat after they have been used for a while?
|
not
marked |
• |
• |
|
|
|
Total
score:
|
5–8
|
2
(4) |
8
(6) |
3–4
|
8
(19) |
29
(20) |
2
|
22
(29) |
28
(29) |
1
|
44
(32) |
27
(34) |
0
|
24
(16) |
8
(11) |
Commentary
Whereas in 1999, there was very little difference in performance between
year 4 and year 8 students, in 2003 year 4 students performed noticeably
worse than in 1999 and year 8 students performed a little better than
in 1999. |