Approach: One
to one |
Focus:
Sort magnetic and non-magnetic
objects based on prior experience and practical investigation and try to generalise. |
|
472k |
Resources: Toy
truck, magnet, bag of objects. |
Questions / instructions:
Some of the things in
this bag are attracted to the magnet. When they are put in the truck, the truck
can be pulled along with the magnet.
|
|
|
|
%
responses
|
y4
|
1.
First I want you to look at all the things in the bag and put them into two groups.
In one group put the things you think will be attracted to the magnet. In the
other group put the things you think will not be attracted to the magnet.
Give student the bag of objects. Allow time. |
|
Prediction
|
Observation
|
wood |
no
|
|
iron bolt |
yes
|
|
plastic |
no
|
|
steel key |
yes
|
|
aluminium key |
no
|
|
rubber |
no
|
|
steel wool |
yes
|
|
aluminium foil |
no
|
|
stone |
no
|
|
|
98
|
97
|
91
|
97
|
9
|
92
|
47
|
54
|
89
|
|
Now
you can try the things and see what happens. |
|
2.
Put each of the things in the back of the truck and see if the magnet can tow
the truck along.
Give student the magnet. Allow time. |
|
Prediction
|
Observation
|
wood |
|
no
|
iron bolt |
|
yes
|
plastic |
|
no
|
steel key |
|
yes
|
aluminium key |
|
no
|
rubber |
|
no
|
steel wool |
|
yes
|
aluminium foil |
|
no
|
stone |
|
no
|
|
99
|
98
|
98
|
97
|
95
|
99
|
94
|
98
|
98
|
|
3.
Now I want you to think of one more thing that would be attracted to the magnet.
Tell me what it is and what it is made of.
Prompt: What kind of metal? |
new
magnetic object identified
|
76
|
4.
Now I want you to think of one more thing that would not be attracted to the magnet.
Tell me what it is and what it is made of. |
new
non-magnetic object identified
|
89
|
5.
Some things attract to magnets and some things don't. I want you to try to tell
me a rule which explains what kind of things are attracted to magnets. |
not
marked
|
a
|
Commentary:
Year 4 students were
very successful in testing the objects. In their earlier predictions, the steel
wool and the aluminium objects produced the least successful predictions. |