Approach: One
to one |
Level:
Year 4
and year 8 |
|
Focus:
Investigating
and evaluating design
|
Resources:
2 pictures
|
|
804kb |
|
|
Questions/instructions:
In this activity you will be thinking about a bike used in the olden
days.
Show picture 1 (bike).
|
|
%
responses
2004 ('00) |
y4
|
y8 |
1. Who might have
ridden this bike? |
|
|
2.
What would they have used the bike for? |
questions
1 and 2 not marked |
• |
• |
|
|
|
|
Show picture 2 (street
scene).
This picture shows the delivery person who uses the bike to deliver
parcels. |
|
|
3.
What things about this bike make it good for the person who used it? |
See
how many things you can tell me. |
prompts: |
Tell
me about the seat. |
|
Tell
me about the shape of the bike frame. |
|
Tell
me about the carrier at the front. |
|
Is
there anything else you
can think of? |
|
mentioned
that the seat has springs to make it more comfortable |
35
(34) |
62
(58) |
mentioned
that the low bar on the frame made it easier to get on and off |
2
(0) |
11
(10) |
mentioned
that the mudguards stop mud and water splashing on the rider |
4
(7) |
11
(13) |
mentioned
that the carrier/basket helps the rider carry parcels |
88
(86) |
87
(91) |
mentioned
that the sign tells who the rider is/works for |
12
(13) |
27
(31) |
mentioned
that the wide tyres make the bike more stable and comfortable |
0
(1) |
1
(4) |
|
Total
score: 4–6 |
1
(0) |
5
(10) |
|
3
|
6
(9) |
24
(21) |
|
2
|
35
(31) |
41
(37) |
|
1
|
49
(51) |
24
(31) |
|
0
|
9
(9) |
6
(1) |
Commentary
Students focused mainly on the basket, seat and sign,
with less attention to the more technical features. About 20 percent
more year 4 than year 8 students explained at least three of the six
features. There was no meaningful change in performance between 2000
and 2004. |